Trump's withdrawal from JCPOA affects prospects of future non-proliferation agreements; Italian Analyst

Trump's withdrawal from JCPOA affects prospects of future non-proliferation agreements; Italian Analyst
News code : 609616

Top Italian analyst believes that if America withdraws unilaterally from an international agreement it has undersigned and the other Parties have complied with, the US reliability would substantially decline leading to bleak prospects for future non-proliferation agreements with Iran and, also, North Korea.

Marco Clementi is Associate Professor of International Relations in Department of Political and Social Sciences in University of Pavia. In an exclusive interview with ILNA, he talked about recent Russia presidential election, encounter between NATO and Moscow and Donald Trump’s possible decision to dissolve JCPOA.

 

ILNA: How do you evaluate recent tensions between Russia and West, concerning the spy case? How does it affect the encounter between NATO and Moscow?

Clementi: On 4 March the former Russian spy Sergei Skripal, his daughter Yulia and a police officer coming to their aid were poisoned with the nerve gas Novichok in Salisbury, UK. Bystanders were exposed to the same risk given traces of the gas nerve have been found around public spaces visited by the Skripals. While delivering an address to Parliament on 12 March, the British Prime Minister stated the “government has concluded that it is highly likely that Russia was responsible for the act” and announced the expulsion of 23 Russian diplomats in retaliation.

On 19 March the Foreign Affairs Council of the European Union condemned the chemical attack and cleared the EU “takes extremely seriously the UK Government’s assessment that it is highly likely that the Russian Federation is responsible”. On 27 March, NATO Secretary General announced NATO would cut the permanent size of its Russian mission from 30 to 20 people, as a “clear and very strong message that there was a cost to Russia’s reckless actions”. All in all, many NATO allies together with Australia, Finland, Macedonia, Sweden and Ukraine have joined the UK in ordering the expulsion of more than 100 Russian diplomats.

This timeline is suggesting that the Western allies have been ready to back the UK position on Russian involvement in the Skripal case even if the British authorities have not offered a clear reconstruction of events. The allies have stated their firm support to London in the face of the “likeliness” of Moscow’s responsibility. On 3 April, in fact, the British Defence Science and Technology Laboratory has communicated it was unable to verify the precise source of the gas nerve used in Salisbury.

On the one hand, the Skripal affair seems to be about Western security; and, one might think the Western allies have shown the promptness of mutual support, even though the Russian threat was uncertain. On the other hand, however, the Skripal affair could be more about Western cohesion. As long as the Russian recklessness is a matter of probability and odds, the Western reaction could result from intra-alliance dynamics rather than external challenges. In this regard, it is noteworthy the poor information on the poisoning has not hindered the formation of a wide and seemingly tight coalition among countries that are bickering on other issues. We cannot rule out the possibility that Russian involvement in the use of chemical agents in the territory of a sovereign state will be proved in the months to come. Up to now, however, the Skripal case seems to have offered the Western allies a low-cost opportunity to show political unity in times of Brexit and American complaints about European contributions to NATO.

 

ILNA: What do you think about the fairness of Russia’s recent presidential election and long period of Putin being in power?

Clementi: On 18 March Vladimir Putin won the Russian Presidential election. The ballots gave Putin the clearest victory since 2000: according to the Russian Central Election Commission, Putin got 76,7% of the vote while his most successful competitor, the communist candidate Pavel Grudinin, had to content with 11,8%. Turnout at the elections was 67,5%: Slightly lower than the 70% share Putin hoped to show the strongest popular support towards the political regime but high enough to emphasize the wide participation to the electoral process.

It seems clear Putin keeps enjoying a wide domestic support and no political challenger is in sight. This could be good news for Russian stability in the years to come. Two caveats, however, are needed to suggest the international perspectives on Russia are more mixed; and, the prospects for the status and influence of the country more uncertain.

Firstly, there are international concerns with the fairness of Russian political process. We will have to wait until the end of May to read the final report on the entire electoral process by the International Election Observation Mission (EOM) of the OSCE Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights and the OSCE Parliamentary Assembly. On 19 March, however, the Spokesperson of the EOM issued a statement of preliminary findings, according to which the “elections were administered efficiently and openly by the Central Electoral Commission and, on the day, conducted in an orderly manner despite shortcomings related to vote secrecy and transparency of counting”. However, the EOM also underlined the elections “were conducted in an overly controlled legal and political environment, marked by continued pressure on critical voices” and it “recorded restrictions on freedoms of assembly, association and expression, as well as on candidate registration, which limited the space for political engagement, resulting in a lack of genuine competition”. In this regard, we cannot but notice that Putin’s most serious competitor, the opposition leader Alexei Navalny, was prevented to participate to the elections.

Secondly, there is the issue of the long period of Putin being in power. At the end of his 4th term, in 2024, President Putin will have been ruling the country since 2000, short of (Putin’s close associate) Dmitry Medvedev’s term from 2008 until 2012. This means the Russian political system is going to get through a quarter of a century without actual political change. However, as long as the Russian political regime and Putin’s leadership have been merging (mandate after mandate), the stability and viability of the former depends more and more on the destiny of the latter. This is especially so since Russia is a hybrid regime where fundamental conflicts over political and socio-economic models have not yet been resolved. Therefore, one might think the greatest challenge Putin has in front of him is not to rule the country until 2024 but to build the conditions for a smooth and effective transition to a post-Putin Russia.

 

ILNA: What do you think about Trump’s possible decision to dissolve JCPOA? How would it affect the relation between US and EU specially in the framework of NATO?

Clementi: On 5 March, the IAEA Director General stated, in front of the IAEA Board of Governors, that “Iran is implementing its nuclear-related commitments” under the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action (JCPOA) and that the JCPOA “represents a significant gain for verification … . If the JCPAO were to fail, it would be a great loss for nuclear verification and for multilateralism”. This very positive assessment of the actual implementation of the JCPAO and its relevance clashes with President Trump’s resolve to abandon the Plan. The newly appointed Secretary of State could be of some help in this regard, since Mike Pompeo is sharply critical of Iran and the nuclear deal in particular.

The Trump Administration hostility towards the JCPOA results from different factors. At the domestic level, Trump wants to distance himself from Obama’s major undertakings. At the regional level, the new relationship with Saudi Arabia and a “power politics” approach to the Middle Eastern theatre do matter. At the global level, Trump has harshly maintained the JCPOA is ineffective in preventing Iranian and international nuclear proliferation.

Trump could be right in pointing out the deal has some flaws such as, for instance, the so-called “sunset clauses”. However, it is highly debatable that things would be better without the agreement. Above all, it is very likely things would be much worse in case Trump unilaterally withdrew from the JCPOA.

If America withdraws unilaterally from an international agreement it has undersigned and the other Parties have complied with, the US reliability would substantially decline leading to bleak prospects for future non-proliferation agreements with Iran and, also, North Korea. International security would suffer accordingly and the Middle East would become even more unstable, thereby putting at greater risk also European security. Thus, it is not unlikely that the decision to abandon the JCPOA would affect also transatlantic relations. At bottom, multilateralism is a core value and practice of the Western security community. Collective security is the core aim of political and military Western cooperation.

Interview: Kamran Baradaran

 

endNewsMessage1
Comments